Argument

An argument is a reasoning by which you try to express the validity of a thesis or idea. It is the central element on which the rest of the content revolves.

The argument is the central axis of the idea that is trying to expose. Its construction must be very strong and apparently irrefutable, since, if the argument is weak, it can be easily countered and it will cause the rest of the thesis, although it may have valid elements and parts, to be totally annulled.

The argument must also be logical, although the idea seems to be contradictory, as with paradoxes, the argument behind it must be logical and eliminate contradictions.

Another element that this argument must have is persuasion, with which we seek to convince the person with whom we talk, or the spectators who observe us.

This argument will have more force, also, if there is a good command of rhetoric. For example, if the argument is well constructed and solid, but we do not know how to express ourselves well, we get stuck, we get very thoughtful, or we have spelling mistakes, if we translate it into a text, the argument will lose force and may not be taken with the seriousness that we expected.

Índice()

    Characteristics of an argument

    Based on its definition and elements, an argument has the following characteristics:

    • The argument defends a thesis or idea.
    • It is internally divided into premises and conclusions.
    • It must be logical and consistent to avoid counterarguments.
    • The good use of rhetoric will reinforce both the content and coherence of the argument and its persuasiveness.
    • It has to be persuasive, it seeks to convince the receiver of the message that we emit.

    Structure of an argument

    The argument is divided, mainly, into two parts: premises and conclusion.

    • Premises: They are the set of ideas that we adopt as true, serving as the basis for the development of the argument. It is an essential element, since if the premises are wrong or false, the argument built on them will be too. For example, in a murder investigation, we need to know for sure certain things to build the case and our argument, such as the murder weapon. If in our investigation we took a knife as a weapon, but it really was a firearm, surely the rest of the investigation will be erroneous, since we start from an erroneous premise.
    • Conclution: It is the thesis derived from the argumentative process. It is also an indispensable element. Well, after elaborating the relationship between the different premises, the conclusion is the idea derived from them. The connection between premise and conclusion must be strong, logical and indestructible. Since from this derives the veracity and persuasiveness of our argument.

    Argument types

    There are many types of arguments, all of them emanate the characteristics indicated and the structure established above:

    • By authority: It is one that is performed by a person of recognized prestige in the field in which it is argued.
    • By analogy: It is one that is carried out by extrapolating other cases similar to ours.
    • Inductive argument: It is characterized by generating arguments through the patterns observed in particular cases.
    • By exemplification: It is the one that is developed using personal experiences or those close to people as an example.
    • Deductive argument: The argument derives from the premises, that is, the particularity is deduced from one or more generalizations.
    • Causal argument: It is based on a cause-effect relationship.
    • By generalization: The observed pattern is generalized in smaller units.

    How to build an argument?

    Building an argument requires several previous steps.

    As we have seen in the previous section, there are numerous types of arguments, these can be referred to as the techniques that can be used to carry them out. Thus, to establish a valid argument, any of them can be used. We have to achieve a logical and consistent relationship between premises and conclusions.

    Generally, we can establish the following steps:

    1. Identify a topic: The first thing is to have a topic on which to argue. Normally it appears in daily discussions or it is known if it is an agreed debate, as it happens in television gatherings.
    2. Find the idea or thesis that we are going to defend: Within this topic, we must identify the position for which we are going to opt.
    3. Prepare the premises: Once we know what we are going to defend, we must identify the premises that will be the basis for the construction of the argument.
    4. Establish conclusions: Looking at the adopted premises and the relationships between them, we adopt a series of conclusions. This step is key, as it is this relationship that will determine the strength, logic, and consistency of the argument.

    Argument example

    Following the steps outlined above, we are going to carry out a practical example, arising from a fictitious situation, visually facilitating the argumentative construction:

    1. Identification of the topic: We are having a family meal and suddenly the debate arises about whether it is better for the competition of public services to be centralized or decentralized. That is, if it is more desirable that the one that develops and implements them is the central or regional and local government.
    2. Find the idea to defend: We believe that it is more desirable for competition to be decentralized, that is, to develop at a regional or local level.
    3. Prepare the premises: We have to find the points in favor of our position. 1st premise: Citizens participate more in the development of policies. 2nd premise: The smaller the scale, the more the cost adapts. 3rd premise: Citizens are the ones who best know their needs.
    4. Conclution: If we accept the adopted premises as true, the conclusion of our argument will be as follows: Decentralization of public policies is more beneficial than centralization, because it allows greater citizen participation as well as being more economically efficient.
    Rate this post

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Go up